valmora: "we three" witches, meeting again (Default)
[personal profile] valmora
I wrote this before I started reading all the fics on [livejournal.com profile] hellblazerslash and decided that it wasn't worth it 'cause I sucked in this fandom, but I'm still glad I wrote it. So far, this is the only fic whose focus is trying to talk about Chas's internal conflict of religion (that is, Christianity's traditional disapproval of homosexuality) vs. his affection for Constantine.



Title: Not Telling
Author: Val Mora
Rating: PG-13 for repeated use of the word fuck.
Pairing: (unrequited) John/Chas
Summary: Chas won't say it.
Disclaimer: So not mine. If they were mine, Keanu Reeves would have been snogging Shia LaBeouf. As he didn't (at least not on screen), we can safely assume I claim no ownership of Hellblazer or Constantine, because John Constantine and Chas Chandler/Kramer are all to DC/Vertigo and whomever else owns any rights to them.

Not Telling

    Chas is never gonna say it.  He has seen John save a hundred, a fucking thousand, souls just by saying stuff, but this is different, and besides, every time John pulls those stunts, he loses a little more of himself to the cigarettes, to the cancer, to uncaring.

    He misses the days when John came back to the car more likely to smile because he was just that much closer to Heaven, when John would explain things to him about magic.  That was before John started coughing up blood every morning, before the diagnosis as a fucking poster child for why early detection is a good thing.  Now, there’s nothing.  Just, “Chas, I need to get here,” with a finger jabbed at a map and “No, Chas.  It’s too dangerous,” that hair spilling into his eyes as he shakes his head.

    He doesn’t think it’s fair that John should still sound almost the same as he used to, because he’s not the same.  John’s just a dead man walking, a damned man walking and exorcising and trying everything he can to get into Heaven when the moment comes.

    And that’s why Chas isn’t going to say anything.  He’s a good Catholic boy – or at least, a good boy, if not Catholic, because he doesn’t think it’s right that John should go to Hell for something stupid he did when he was young, even if it’s fair, and Chas figures questioning Catholic dogma makes you not Catholic – and he sure doesn’t want to wish Hell on anyone, let alone John.  And, well, telling would be Insta-damnation, like Instant Ramen only a lot less fun.

    He had Instant Ramen with John the other day.  It was a nasty exorcism, and afterwards, John was just gonna finish the cigarette and crash on the couch, but Chas made Instant Ramen for the two of them because he knows John doesn’t eat enough anyway.  Never feels hungry, special thanks to his grade-A terminal lung cancer.

    They sat there, half-illuminated by the light of the dim bulb, and Chas watched John eat, the noodles wrapped around the plastic fork, and then drinking the salt broth straight from the bowl to finish it.

    John doesn’t buy spoons.  He said, once, the day he eats Instant Ramen with a spoon is the day he gives up, checks himself in to the hospital, and lets the cancer take him.

    When he picks up takeout, Chas makes sure to open all the plastic-silverware packages and throw out every single spoon.

    He saw a spoon by the side of the road the other day, right by a gutter, and he mused on whether or not littering ought to be a sin.  Which made him, of course, think of John.  It’s really all he thinks about these days, John and demons and angels and death.  Oh, and sleep, because it’s one of those things nobody ever gets enough of, especially John.

    John, the one person in any fucking realm he’s ever been in lo-

    And that’s why he’s never going to say it.  Because good Catholic boys don’t have nightmares about their mentors dying, don’t find that their mentors’ lung cancer is a waking nightmare, don’t wake up from dreams of having sex with their mentors.

    Which is why he won’t say it.  Saying it will make it real, and he doesn’t want it to be real.  If it’s real, it’s wrong, and Chas knows where wrongness gets you.

    Eventually, John will right that wrong he did all those years ago, and when he goes, he’ll go up.

    Chas won’t say it, but he hopes like nothing else that Heaven takes boys who aren’t good Catholics.


Date: 2005-03-31 09:20 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] formerlydf.livejournal.com
I really liked this, even though I like Constantine/Balthazar more than Constantine/Chas. I liked how you made John change from hopeful to jaded because he can't have started out that way. I think the best sentence, though, was
"And, well, telling would be Insta-damnation, like Instant Ramen only a lot less fun."
because it just made me crack up. And I liked the line about questioning Catholic dogma because I don't think I've ever actually heard anyone use the word dogma before.

I really liked that there was an entire paragraph about Ramen noodles. It's the little things that make stories great. *grins cheerily*

~DF (DevotedFan)

Date: 2005-04-01 12:06 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] valmora.livejournal.com
I don't think I've ever actually heard anyone use the word dogma before.

Kevin Smith made a movie with that title. Its entire premise is a couple of angels-who-annoyed-God-and-were-sent-to-Wisconsin who are exploiting a loophole in Catholicism. It's actually where I learned the word.

Date: 2005-03-31 10:29 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] pourtant.livejournal.com
Oh, oh. Very interesting. I like the idea that Chas doesn't say anything mostly because he wants to protect John (and himself at the same time). And this kind of innocent self-imposed denial he is in, trying to convince himself that if he doesn't say it, it's okay because then it doesn't exist. Nicely done!

Insta-damnation, like Instant Ramen only a lot less fun.
Hee! XD

When he picks up takeout, Chas makes sure to open all the plastic-silverware packages and throw out every single spoon.
--> Loved that sentence. Not quite sure why.

Date: 2005-03-31 11:49 pm (UTC)
ext_17864: (constantine)
From: [identity profile] cupiscent.livejournal.com
This is a very nice little bit of character development! Great Chas voice, really works for me, the uncertainties and the certainties, the double-guessing, the rationalising (I think he's a very rational person, possibly an over-thinker). So yes, the building it up to the cutting off of the thought - I think it really works well. There's this great lurking tone of desperation curtailed.

And the whole spoon thing? Was just great.

Date: 2005-04-01 12:09 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] valmora.livejournal.com
And the whole spoon thing? Was just great.

Glad you thought so. I started it on a tangent and then decided I liked it too much to give it up.

Date: 2005-03-31 11:55 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] sunhawk.livejournal.com
Except the Chinese man remark, which i found distracting, this was a nicely written story ^_^

Date: 2005-04-01 12:03 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] valmora.livejournal.com
It was supposed to be just one of those random comments that people interject into their speech. Guess it didn't work so well. Thank you for that notice, though - I thought about deleting it myself, decided not to, and then decided to thanks to you.

Date: 2005-04-01 03:08 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] sunhawk.livejournal.com
i'm glad i didn't offend you, i just thought it was an interesting natural reaction of mine to note :) It was weird, the moment i read "like a Chinese man" i started thinking "do Chinese men eat like that? Do they eat instant noodles or do they make them from scratch?" and then i tried to remember what my housemate from last year did, she was Chinese LOL So you can see how i lost the story there for a moment.

Date: 2005-04-01 03:37 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] valmora.livejournal.com
One of my best friends is Chinese and she eats instant ramen all the time, so I guess that was what I was thinking of - she eats all the noodles first and then drinks the broth straight from the bowl. It's a curious habit, and not one I see very often in Westerners, though I've seen a number of my Asian friends do it.

I'm not offended; I was worried you were!

Date: 2005-04-01 07:32 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] sunhawk.livejournal.com
LOL no i wasn't offended, i just happen to drink the broth as well and i'm not Chinese

Date: 2005-04-01 02:07 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] ravenwolf1414.livejournal.com
This was just wonderful. It was so much lik hero-worship, only much sweeter and softer and sadder. Interesting to think that *Chas* might be the one not to make it into heaven, instead of John. And also, nice job of revealing Catholic values to be the barrier they are to Chas's feelings. This was all fantastic, just sort of subtly funny ('insta-damnation' *snicker snicker*) and bittersweet. Thanks.

Not Telling - Review

Date: 2005-04-13 02:05 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] aefallen.livejournal.com
he loses a little more of himself to the cigarettes, to the cancer, to uncaring.
I love this so much. I love the way you see that people can lose themselves to more than just the physical - the uncaring's a psychic - or spiritual - death that John's suffering from, just as surely as cancer. Losing himself to uncaring - I love this one so much.

He misses the days when John came back to the car more likely to smile because he was just that much closer to Heaven, when John would explain things to him about magic.
Now this is beautiful. Especially about John being that much closer to Heaven, and the way it made John feel and act better, like things were looking up for all of them.

That was before John started coughing up blood every morning
I love the way you encapsulate time, here, showing such a marked difference in the before and after. You have so much change within that simple line, and there's such a sense of past and present in those sentences alone. Excellent.

It was a nasty exorcism, and afterwards, John was just gonna finish the cigarette and crash on the couch
I love the way this sounds just like what John would do.

but Chas made Instant Ramen for the two of them because he knows John doesn’t eat enough anyway.
And, I just loved this so much.

When he picks up takeout, Chas makes sure to open all the plastic-silverware packages and throw out every single spoon.
And then I just loved this even more.

he mused on whether or not littering ought to be a sin
I melted at this. I can just imagine Chas lighting on this thought and turning it over in his mind. I love the way that, in Chas's mind, all roads lead to John, one way or the other.

John, the one person in any fucking realm he’s ever been in lo-
I love any fucking realm. And the way Chas cuts his train of thought off right there, as if he's been learning way too much from John, the way he's become (or always was) so conscious, and so careful, of what sends one up to heaven or down to hell.

Eventually, John will right that wrong he did all those years ago, and when he goes, he’ll go up.
I love Chas's sheer faith in John, his iron-clad belief that John will be able to put things right for himself.
Page generated Mar. 24th, 2026 12:59 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios